Free dunkirk papers, essays, and research papers dunkirk - a great deliverance or great disaster - dunkirk was a great deliverance and a great disaster - (ajp taylor) is there sufficient evidence in sources a to f to support this interpretation. I'm writing an essay, and i have to have two points of view i believe that dunkirk was a triumph, but i need to know some reasons as to why someone may think it was a disaster. Dunkirk can also be considered to be a disaster as it was a tactical defeat followed by a rescue that the royal navy couldn't carry out effectively by itself the number of evacuees is a momentous factor in people's decision to view dunkirk as a miracle. Dunkirk was called a miracle by winston churchill and how britain were still up, back and ready to fight another day many see as a triumph in itself an example of this is source b2, a cartoon by british artist david low, published in the london newspaper on the 8th of june 1940. More essay examples on world war ii rubric overall, nearly 40,000 pieces of equipment were 'surrendered' to the enemy, including 17,000 machine guns, 12,000 field guns, 2,800 anti-aircraft guns and 475 tanks.
The battle of france, of which dunkirk was the final chapter, was a disaster, although eduardo j belgrano's description of 'unmitigated' is incorrect the evacuation, operation dynamo, was conceived, planned and began operation in six days. Related as and a level international history, 1945-1991 essays nbsp was dunkirk a miracle or a disaster - gcse history - marked by : the evacuation of the bef from dunkirk in may 1940 was seen as a miracle to there are many reasons why dunkirk is seen as a disaster. Operation dynamo, the evacuation from dunkirk essay questions for college students of 27 may-4 june 1940, is one of the most celebrated military events in dunkirk miracle or disaster essay british history, and yet it was the direct.
146th uk, then simply from the moment that the dunkirk miracle or disaster essay french defenses at sedan and on the meuse were broken at the end ssat practice test essay of the second week of may, only a rapid. 'so long as the english tongue survives, the word dunkirk will be spoken with reverence in that harbour, such a hell on earth as never blazed before, at the end of a lost battle, the rags and blemishes that had hidden the soul of democracy fell away. The battle of dunkirk lasted from around may 25 to june 3, 1940 after the phony war, the battle of france began on 10 may, 1940 german armour burst through the ardennes region and advanced rapidly driving north in the so-called sickle cut. Some people thought that it was a disaster because the english did not accomplish anything when over at dunkirk, all what they did was stand around.
To summarize, dunkirk can be considered a spectacular failure on the part of the allies, rather than a victory conversely, dunkirk can be considered a success in a number of ways the initial rescue target for the british navy was set at around 30,000. Was the battle of dunkirk a triumph or disaster for britain a brief summary of the main arguments for and against category education show more show less. Dunkirk is referred to as a miracle simply because the germans should have, and could have, easily wiped out the british expedition the german high command halted as the army was about to go for the kill (on orders from hitler who at times would lose his nerve temporarily. The soldiers fled to dunkirk and 328,000 men out of 400,000 were saved, but was this really a miracle or a disaster after world war i, the maginot line was built on the french and german border in hope of preventing further attack. This source looks at at how the evacuation of dunkirk was portrayed by britain and then looks a range of different sources of the evacuation the aim of the task is for the students to judge whether the evacuation was a triumph or disaster using the evide.
Dunkirk was a miracle of deliverance from the 27th of may to the 4th of june, there were the nine days of evacuation of british, french, belgian and dutch soldiers alike they were trapped in the small town of dunkirk due to the port that was there. Dunkirk did also have upsides it was a miracle how many people were actually saved and how british fishermen were prepared to sacrifice their lives to help save the soldiers america also agreed that it was a miracle as they were stunned how many were rescued and unharmed. Dunkirk is called a miracle in the history of britain but was it really a miracle or just a great disaster hidden from the public in may 1940 germans had the allies trapped at the coast of dunkirk in france and were closing in winston churchill decided to call in an evacuation plan and rescued 338,000 thousand soldiers through the help of the english navy and 860 privately owned naval. The dunkirk evacuation, code-named operation dynamo, also known as the miracle of dunkirk, was the evacuation of allied soldiers during world war ii from the beaches and harbour of dunkirk, in the north of france, between 26 may and 4 june 1940.
A report on the evacuation at dunkirk 1802 words | 7 pages beyond question, the evacuation at dunkirk was the culmination of a major military disaster for the british military, one of the worst it ever suffered in its history. Was dunkirk 'a miracle' or 'a disaster'in this following essay i will be discussing the different views and military tactics used for evacuating both french and english soldiers from dunkirk.